They are basically the same shape, give or take a few odd fixing holes etc, which can be welded up or drilled as needed. Also the gussets to the inner wings may be different (hole size and shape), but these can be swapped, or made at home (1.2mm thick!!!) If you do cut the big hole, be sure to put the raised rim round it, for stiffness and originality, or for £32.99, Somerford can sell you a "hole" ready for welding in, or more correctly, the entire area including various small holes too.
http://www.somerford...products_id=599
Presumably your van does have a rubber mounted subframe? If not, the extra work is not worth the price difference.....
That seems to be a good price for such a complex panel.
You may want to seam weld it all before fitting, and seam weld to the rest of the shell (double seam, inside and out, at the lap joints, e.g. toeboard/floor). It will make a significant difference to crash protection and may just save your life one day (although we hope your van will never be in an accident, of course). Some modern cars are seam welded in vital areas for that reason. And, it increases stiffness, so reduces noise and improves handling, albeit marginally. I would definitely seam weld the top edge of the bracket for the engine steady, as it helps prevent really annoying fracture later, and it is also a good opportunity to fit stiffening plates in case you shold want to fit a subframe solid mount kit later.
Bulkhead change is a huge job, and if you are doing it, I guess that you value your van highly. Sadly I had to scrap a van in about 1973, as economics of that era meant that repair was not viable, DIY MIG welders did not exist, and the local BMC dealer was allegedly unable to obtain panels like inner wings, which is really all that it needed. It was a lovely vehicle to drive, and if I ever find a good one at the right price, I will be buying it.
Edited by tiger99, 22 December 2013 - 12:43 PM.