LOL, its unlikely the speakers are naff in this instance, as i know most of the mid-bass' in the 75s were Alpine OEM units. They will not be badged Almpine anywhere, not even on the magnet, just trust me they are.
It sounds very much like you have a phase issue. I.e you have the positive and neg of the speakers on the wrong way accross the pair. You can chack the polarity of them real easy on an AA battery.
Will give it a go changing the wires around tonight and post how i get on...... when its the right way around the cones push oout?
Cheers
BM
Use an AA battery with some wire from each end to the terminals of the speaker. If the cone moves out, you know that the positive nipple on the battery must have the wire going to the positive speaker connection. Get the same result from the other side and its in phase.

Does that make sense?